Uncle Charlie's Bella Pizza Menu (2025 Update)

Welcome to Uncle Charlie's Bella Pizza, a beloved gem nestled at 914 Main St, New Milford, PA. This family-run establishment is renowned for its authentic New York City-style pizza and a diverse menu that includes deliciously crafted subs and burgers.

Customers rave about the exceptional quality and taste of the food. One satisfied diner, Bear Sayer, emphasizes that after trying numerous local options, Uncle Charlie’s stands out for its freshly made offerings. The thick Sicilian-style crusts and a variety of hot and cold subs leave taste buds tingling.

The inviting atmosphere and attentive service create a memorable dining experience. As Brian Mirra shares, the friendly staff and reasonable prices make it the perfect spot for all ages. Whether you're indulging in a classic cheese slice or a hearty eggplant parmigiana, every dish is a testament to Uncle Charlie’s commitment to freshness and flavor. Stop by and discover your new favorite culinary haven!